| 1901 | 1900 | 1899 | 1898 | 1897 | 1896 | 1895 |
| Seasons | Champs | Runner Up |
Best Finish |
Worst Finish |
Longest Run |
Current Run |
||
| 1st Tier | 0 | |||||||
| 2nd Tier | 0 | |||||||
| 3rd Tier | 0 | |||||||
| 4th Tier | 0 |
| 9 - 1 | 1894-95 | D2 | Walsall |
| 8 - 0 | 1895-96 | D2 | Rotherham Town |
| 5 - 0 | 1900-01 | D2 | Walsall |
| 5 - 0 | 1899-00 | D2 | Gainsborough |
| 5 - 0 | 1899-00 | D2 | Loughborough |
| 5 - 0 | 1896-97 | D2 | Newcastle United |
| 5 - 0 | 1895-96 | D2 | Port Vale |
| 5 - 0 | 1895-96 | D2 | Loughborough |
| 5 - 1 | 1894-95 | D2 | Notts County |
| 4 - 0 | 1900-01 | D2 | Grimsby Town |
| 1 - 6 | 1898-99 | D2 | Luton Town |
| 0 - 5 | 1894-95 | D2 | Burton Swifts |
| 1 - 4 | 1897-98 | D2 | Lincoln City |
| 1 - 4 | 1895-96 | D2 | Loughborough |
| 0 - 3 | 1898-99 | D2 | Birmingham City |
| 0 - 3 | 1898-99 | D2 | Loughborough |
| 0 - 3 | 1897-98 | D2 | Arsenal |
| 1 - 3 | 1898-99 | D2 | Glossop North End |
| 1 - 3 | 1894-95 | D2 | Walsall |
| 0 - 2 | 1899-00 | D2 | Port Vale |