| 1912 | 1911 | 1910 | 1909 | 1908 | 1907 | 1906 |
| Seasons | Champs | Runner Up |
Best Finish |
Worst Finish |
Longest Run |
Current Run |
||
| 1st Tier | 0 | |||||||
| 2nd Tier | 0 | |||||||
| 3rd Tier | 0 | |||||||
| 4th Tier | 0 |
| 9 - 1 | 1907-08 | FAC | Worksop Town |
| 9 - 2 | 1906-07 | D2 | Glossop North End |
| 7 - 0 | 1910-11 | D2 | Lincoln City |
| 7 - 0 | 1905-06 | D2 | Port Vale |
| 7 - 1 | 1906-07 | D2 | Chesterfield |
| 6 - 0 | 1905-06 | D2 | Blackpool |
| 6 - 0 | 1905-06 | D2 | Barnsley |
| 6 - 1 | 1905-06 | D2 | Leyton Orient |
| 5 - 1 | 1906-07 | D2 | Bradford City |
| 5 - 1 | 1905-06 | D2 | Hull City |
| 0 - 5 | 1906-07 | D2 | Lincoln City |
| 1 - 4 | 1908-09 | D1 | Middlesbrough |
| 1 - 4 | 1907-08 | D1 | Liverpool |
| 1 - 4 | 1911-12 | D2 | Birmingham City |
| 1 - 4 | 1911-12 | D2 | Leyton Orient |
| 1 - 4 | 1910-11 | D2 | Derby County |
| 1 - 4 | 1905-06 | D2 | Lincoln City |
| 0 - 3 | 1907-08 | D1 | Manchester City |
| 0 - 3 | 1907-08 | D1 | Everton |
| 0 - 3 | 1907-08 | D1 | Sheffield United |